If the contest is only about winning, then I believe that David Archuleta will win. I don’t doubt that he has a very very vast following. I won’t even question why. He’s a good singer, not to mention, charming.
But if the contest is really about finding an American Idol, a really, really good performer, dynamic and will, by the way, sell multi-million albums, then the voting public of American Idol ought to choose David Cook.
It’s the penultimate night of American Idol season 7. Naturally, millions of people were tuned in to see who will be crowned winner this time. If Simon Cowell could foretell the future, and correctly at that, then David A. will probably win. As Simon saw it, David A. delivered a mighty blow against David C. It was, in his words, a “knock-out.” But is that enough?…
This brings to mind the first boxing bout between Manny Pacquiao and Juan Manuel Marquez. During that fight, Pacquiao was able to deliver heavy blows against Marquez. Many thought that Marquez was certain to lose. But come decision time, the judges announced a draw between the two.
Of course, I’m not saying that Pacquiao is the Filipino equivalent of David Archuleta. God knows Pacquiao can only sing as good as David A.’s foot. The point is, delivering deathly blows sometimes is not enough… assuming these were in fact deathly blows.
But then again, as my friend had pointed out earlier when I voiced the same opinion to him, I may be biased in favor of David Cook. Perhaps, that is the reason why even though I’ve agreed with Simon Cowell’s opinions for this season, no matter how harsh they may have been, I cannot bring myself to see it his way this time. The way I see it, the voting populace will not consider only their performance for tonight. Otherwise, they should have just made it a one-show season. It’s not just an ordinary elimination night where the one with the highest votes will have another shot. After tonight, regardless of whatever happens tomorrow, the two Davids are out on their own now. They will no longer have to concern themselves with whatever the three judges will say of them. As soon as they left that stage tonight, their concern is so much bigger, or at least it should be.